Peer Editing Checklist and Feedback Forms


Here are 20 peer editing checklists that will help your students provide real, detailed, and meaningful feedback.  You’ll be able to edit them to meet your students’ need.

You’ll love having specific tasks for your students to use for peer (and self) review.

Ready to use today!

Category: Tag:


Make peer editing and review focused and effective for your students with these peer editing checklists. Rather than shallow, vague suggestions, you’ll teach the elements of writing with focused tasks that challenge your students to find evidence from the paper.

Students will provide better peer reviews, understand the writing requirements as they analyze a peer’s paper, and be able to analyze their own writing more effectively.

No more feedback like:  “this is good” or “write more.”  Your students will learn how to give real and valuable writing feedback.

Each peer editing checklist focuses on a specific writing component.

Here’s what you get:

20 different editable peer editing checklists to help reviewers identify:

  • Identifying focus — What’s the big idea
  • Organization
  • Rhetorical devices
  • Supporting facts, examples, and details
  • Sentence structure & variety
  • Purpose & audience
  • Voice
  • Word choice
  • Transitions
  • Introductions & conclusions
  • Using ideas from various sources
  • Works cited & parenthetical citation
  • Embedded quotes
  • Narrative Writing
  • Persuasive Writing
  • Argument Writing
  • Response to a literary or expository text
  • Research
  • Opinion Writing
  • “Build your own” editable feedback form

Reasons to love this lesson:

  • Editable — so you can create a feedback form that meets your students’ needs
  • Aligned with CCSS and TEKS
  • Perfect for mini lessons – teach and students can apply to their own papers or those they review
  • More than a checklist! Students need to prove what they know by finding evidence from the paper
  • Perfect for differentiation and scaffolding
  • Ready to use! Just print the pages you need!
  • Create your own custom feedback with the editable form

Enjoy teaching peer reviews and make them meaningful for students

If you’re looking for a bit more help, this post will help.

With gratitude for all you do,



There are no reviews yet.

Only logged in customers who have purchased this product may leave a review.

You may also like…

  • Everything you need to teach expository writing

    Informative /Explanatory Expository Writing Lessons

    Add to cart
  • How to Write a Memoir: Personal Narrative Writing

    Add to cart
  • Teach Narrative Writing with Mini Lessons

    Add to cart